Christianity Today August 31, 2026 8 min signal 2026-08-31

O. Palmer Robertson's long defense of covenantal theology

Archived text mirror, captured for personal reading when the Signal ran. Formatting is approximate — read the original at the source.

Christianity Today

August 31, 2026

- Facebook

- X

- WhatsApp

- Telegram

Facebook / Edits by CT

In December 1973, members of the Presbyterian Church in the United States (PCUS) revolted against their church leadership over liberal drift. Affiliated seminaries had denied the infallibility of the Bible. Education committees had questioned Mosaic authorship of the Bible’s first five books. Fearing even the beloved Westminster Confession was at risk of being watered down, 296 delegates gathered in Birmingham, Alabama, to launch a new denomination.

Decrying a milquetoast Christianity, 36-year-old Owen Palmer Robertson, a seminary professor in a suit with a paisley tie, addressed the assembly. Behind dark-rimmed glasses, he lambasted the modern spirit of promoting faith over “the faith” and caring that someone believed rather than what someone believed.

“Agonize for the faith!” he declared. “Don’t just sit there when men speak untruth, or leave the truth unspoken. Agonize!”

Thanks for signing up.

Explore more newsletters—don’t forget to start your free 60-day trial of CT to get full access to all articles in every newsletter.

Sorry, something went wrong. Please try again.

And thus began the Presbyterian Church in America (PCA).

Robertson has spent the rest of his life pursuing biblical theology in the pulpit, in the classroom, and on the page. Turning 89 years old today, Robertson has provided Christians a practical example of commitment to the Reformed heritage: planting churches, teaching at seminaries, and serving in Africa. But much of his legacy lies in his 21 books—with at least one more pending—written to explain “the faith that was once for all entrusted to God’s holy people” (Jude v. 3).

Born on August 31, 1937, in Jackson, Mississippi, Robertson was the fourth of five children in a family that regularly attended the local Presbyterian church. He experienced personal faith at age 15 through the preaching of Billy Graham, according to The Hope Fulfilled, a collection of essays in honor of Robertson, which provides many of the anecdotes and testimonies that follow. During his youth, he grieved the drowning death of a brother, and his parents’ “mischievous boys” nearly burned down the woods surrounding the family home. He also used his skills as a state yo-yo champion to preach the gospel in Black neighborhoods.

Shortly after salvation came a call to ministry. He married at age 19 while attending Belhaven College in his hometown, and in 1962 he graduated from Westminster Theological Seminary (WTS) in Glenside, Pennsylvania. The PCUS ordained him three years later. His first pastorate was in Picayune, Mississippi, and beginning in 1967, he taught biblical theology at Reformed Theological Seminary (RTS) in Jackson.

Looking back at that time, Robert Cannada, chancellor emeritus of RTS, called Robertson “the best classroom teacher I had.” Dominic Aquila, president emeritus of New Geneva Theological Seminary, recalled the groundswell of student demand at RTS for Robertson’s Old Testament theology class when students learned he was taking a position at WTS the following academic year. Accommodating the request, Robertson held an extra class at 7 a.m. four days a week for the entire academic year.

After Robertson arrived at Westminster in 1971, his faculty colleagues teased him about his Southern accent. People laughed him out of a Philadelphia sub shop when he mispronounced hoagie. But within five years he had planted the first PCA church north of the Mason-Dixon line in Malvern, Pennsylvania, a church that initially met at his home as he offered his students popcorn along with vespers, or evening prayers.

At WTS, Robertson also encountered his first and greatest controversy—on the role of faith versus works in personal salvation. In 1975, debate centered on professor Norman Shepherd’s theology, when his students professed views to various church bodies that violated the Westminster Confession. Robertson viewed his colleague’s perspective as threatening the doctrine of salvation by faith alone by calling one’s works an additional “instrument” of justification. In 1982, WTS dismissed Shepherd, but the issue lingered in Presbyterian circles.

Three years earlier, Robertson had taken a new position at the PCA-affiliated Covenant Theological Seminary in St. Louis. During a six-month sabbatical in England, he began writing what became his magnum opus, The Christ of the Covenants, which distilled classical Reformed theology into an accessible text. From Adam to Noah to Moses to David and onward to Jesus, he wrote that grace unfolds progressively and culminates in Christ.

Covenantal theology was not controversial at the seminary, but then-president William Barker II recalled that Robertson came with an amillennialist perspective (the belief that Christ’s 1,000-year reign in Revelation is symbolic for the present church age) to a largely premillennialist (the belief that Christ will return and reign for a literal 1,000 years) body. Even so, he quickly won over the faculty. One of the staunchest supporters of the standard institutional view whispered, “Pure gold!” to a colleague after hearing the new professor interview.

Barker asked Robertson to avoid bringing the justification controversy to Covenant, and Robertson complied. But after WTS dismissed Shepherd and Robertson summarized the dispute for Covenant’s theological journal, the faculty narrowly voted to suppress its publication for fear of offending Westminster and other Reformed seminaries.

In 1985, Robertson accepted the call to pastor a Presbyterian church in Maryland near Washington, DC, on the condition that he could devote himself to writing. Another book on covenants followed, as well as a treatise on Jonah. During these seven years of ministry, Robertson also started a Christian school and planted two more churches.

But he also felt the stirrings of his early call to missions and in 1992 joined his sister and brother-in-law at African Bible Colleges (ABC) in Malawi. In 2004, he moved to Uganda to establish another campus there. Altogether, he spent 27 years on the continent, strengthening its local church leadership.

W. Wilson Benton, an ABC board member, called Robertson an “indispensable expression of God’s grace” to the African seminary. But even while based in Africa, Robertson spent alternate semesters at Knox Theological Seminary in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, where students left with their “hearts on fire” from his passionate teaching, said Michael Milton, a former administrator, who praised Robertson’s evangelistic style of instruction.

But three years after moving to Africa, his wife died from cancer. Burdened with grief, Robertson nonetheless continued in the ministry and met an English missionary woman more than two decades his junior. They fell in love and married in 1996, and she won over his three adult daughters, said one, with her “charm and devotion” to God. The new couple would eventually add three sons to the Robertson family.

Throughout his time in Africa, Robertson continued to publish—often on controversial themes. In 1993, he argued for the cessation of prophetic gifts in The Final Word. In 2000, he opposed Zionist dispensationalism in The Israel of God. And in 2002, he examined the Bible’s perspective on cultural issues with The Genesis of Sex.

But the lingering issues surrounding Shepherd arose again when Robertson’s former colleague published a book summarizing his views in 2000. Three years later, Robertson resurfaced his original unpublished response to the debate from Shepherd’s tenure at WTS when he published The Current Justification Controversy—20 years after it was written. In its contemporary introduction, James Robbins lamented that in Shepherd’s dismissal back in 1982, “the cancer of neolegalism was not killed.”

Denominations began to act, however. In 2004, the Reformed Church in the United States called Shepherd’s views “another gospel.” In 2006, the Orthodox Presbyterian Church rejected them as “deficient.” And though the PCA did not address Shepherd directly, in 2006 it opposed the Federal Vision concept of justification, noting that much of it was based on his views.

Yet it would be wrong to depict Robertson as consumed solely by controversy. The Christ of the Prophets continued his focus on covenantal theology in 2008. In 2015, The Flow of the Psalms did the same, followed two years later by The Christ of Wisdom, exploring Job, Proverbs, and Ecclesiastes.

Robertson returned to the US in 2019 and founded Consummation Ministries to continue his dedication to classic Reformation theology. But the name also hints at the near completion of his academic journey.

After recovering from rectal cancer in 2021, he published the first of a three-volume series called Christ of the Consummation, arguing that no new prophecies or promises are needed—only their fulfillment in the kingdom of God. After the initial exploration of the Gospels, volume 2—released in 2025—focused on Acts and the letters of Paul. Volume 3 awaits, examining the General Epistles and Revelation.

Throughout his long career, faithful to his original charge to Presbyterian delegates in 1973, Robertson has agonized in defense of the unity of Scripture. Through tragedy and joy, in church and classroom, he has promoted it. And at the 50th General Assembly of the PCA in Memphis, Tennessee, in 2023, he urged his fellow elders to honor their heritage of theology, holiness, and missionary service.

“The entire system of doctrine … holds together,” Robertson said. “It’s impossible to pull out one part without the whole thing unraveling.”

- More from Jayson Casper

- Facebook

- X

- WhatsApp

- Telegram

### PCA’s 50th Anniversary Comes During a Season of Grief

Megan Fowler

### The 1991 Book Awards

### ‘Concerned’ Faction Spurns Presbyterian Accommodation

Joseph M. Hopkins

### Died: Frank Barker Jr., PCA Founder with Passion for Evangelism