Manufactured proof
Date
07/30/2026
Hosted By
Manufactured proof
0:00
WORLD Radio - Manufactured proof
Author and apologist Abdu Murray warns that AI fakery can turn spiritual curiosity into cynicism when online testimonies depend on images and evidence no one can trust.
Lily Jay Image from a YouTube video
Editor's note: The following text is a transcript of a podcast story. To listen to the story, click on the arrow beneath the headline above.
MARY REICHARD, HOST: Coming next: AI and Truth!
An Australian influencer who goes by Lily Jay started using her online platform to promote her conversion to Islam last year.
Jay sometimes wears a hijab over her blonde hair and has been documenting her new faith in front of her three million Instagram followers. She often posts videos in which she asks ChatGPT faith questions.
JAY: Hey ChatGPT, I have a question. Does Islam oppress women?
MYRNA BROWN, HOST: But earlier this month ABC News Australia exposed a trail of AI-generated fakery…involving an orphanage Jay says her foundation established in Uganda. Differentiating between the truth and fake AI content is growing more difficult. Joining us to help us make sense of it all is Abdu Murray. He’s a former Muslim who converted to Christianity… and the author of, Fake ID: How AI and Identity Ideology Are Collapsing Reality and What to Do About It.
Good morning Abdu
ABDU: Good morning, Myrna.
BROWN: Lily Jay seems to be part of a growing trend of young people using conversion to Islam as a tool to influence the masses. What are you seeing?
ABDUL Well, I think that you're absolutely right, and I think that what's interesting about the Lily J case specifically is the way and how she looks, really. A big part of it is that she doesn't look like a typical convert to Islam. We might think of someone who's Middle Eastern or Asian or South Asian or African who might convert to Islam because of the influence of Islam in those areas. Lily J is a blonde woman with blue eyes, fair complexion. She's a former actress and singer, and really has this like persona about her, and so she used her conversion to Islam as an influencer to really generate quite a bit of buzz, especially now that Islam is in the news. But, what's interesting is that people have looked at it and said, "What's going on here exactly? Because here's this woman with an Australian accent, referencing Islamic materials and sources and using the Arabic words for those things, but she doesn't always wear the hijab. She doesn't always do that, so she looks almost like a glam influencer.
BROWN: And so part of the allure if you will, is because she doesn’t fit the stereotype. Is that it?
ABDU: Yes, I think also what you're seeing is the allure of the appearance being as strong as the arguments in favor of a religious conversion. So you hear you have this person who you would think, given their environment, the way they look, the way they act, all these things would never convert to Islam, given sort of the view that we have that it oppresses women. And here she is acting like she's found liberation in Islam as a Western woman, and so it really does create a specter that hey, maybe if I'm a woman and I'm sitting around thinking I don't know about my life, I don't know ultimate purpose, I want to find truth, and then you stumble across Lily J, and you're thinking, look how confident and how able she is to be sort of maintain her Western identity, but also be a Muslim. Maybe I can do that too. And so, independent of the strength of the arguments in favor of her worldview, her appearance is as compelling as anything else might be because of the way she acts.
BROWN: Gone are the days that you can distinguish what is real and what is fake by simply looking at an image or video. You say we’ve gone from “post-truth” to “post-trust.” Talk about where we are right now in this AI age and where you think it’s going.
ABDU: So many things are easily generatable and can get such influence before anybody calls it out that we don't know what's true anymore, and that's at the at the heart of what I call reality collapse. Reality itself doesn't collapse, but our perception of reality collapses to the point now where we just don't trust anything. I mean, I make the joke oftentimes that if UFOs actually did come to the Earth and aliens actually did arrive and want to speak to our leaders, and we saw it on video, the first thing we'd say is, "Well, that's AI. We wouldn't even believe it. Now, what's interesting is we…it's not that we distrust AI it’s that we distrust the people using AI, and AI allows some dishonest people to do some dishonest things.
BROWN: You’ve written, “those three million followers Lily Jay has on social media stand to lose so much, especially when evidence is manufactured.” What do you mean by that?
ABDU: If you're a person who's been skeptical, who's been thinking through what worldview is true, and you find her and you get excited about maybe Islam is true, look at the proof she's offering on her videos, and then you find out that her videos also offer AI deep fakery. Now what do you do? The cost isn't just to Lily Jay’s reputation; it's actually to the view that the person has as to whether or not they can know if anything is true. And so, skepticism that turned to belief is now transformed into cynicism. And how tough is it to break through cynicism, indeed.
BROWN: What a ripple effect, right?
ABDU: Indeed.
BROWN: Wrapping up here…from a Christian perspective, celebrity-conversions are not uncommon and often end in disappointment. Is there a lesson for the church here?
ABDU: I can tell you, as someone who's converted to Christianity from Islam, there was a temptation and to go onto platforms and put a microphone in front of my face immediately after I converted because Christians were so elated. I still needed a lot more seasoning, a lot more maturity. Thank God, circumstances got in the way to keep me from putting a microphone or a camera in front of me. Now the temptation is far more because with the proliferation of social media, we can make something out of our converts as well. Lily J is simply the Islamic version of what we've done in many, many ways, and I could list the cases off. And my guess is that listeners already know who I'm speaking of, the number of celebrity Christians who have either said something completely theologically off mark or have gone off the rails emotionally or socially in some way, and so we get disappointed. The lesson here, here's the lesson, is that while we rejoice with conversion, we never forget two things. The first thing is this: is that Jesus is not only our Savior, but He's our Lord, which means that we are to be discipled by Him, and so celebrity is not a part of the discipleship process. It is the antithesis of the discipleship process because the Bible says for us to humble ourselves under the mighty hand of God, and at the right time He will exalt us. And so, the more we try to generate platform, especially as new converts, the more danger we're in of undoing the good we've done through the news of our conversion and bringing ill repute to the church and to Christ Himself.
BROWN: Speaker, Author, Abdu Murray thank you for your time today.
ABDU: Thank you, Myrna.
WORLD Radio transcripts are created on a rush deadline. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of WORLD Radio programming is the audio record.