Vahe Shahinian was offered a line of credit worth $750,000 at an interest rate just under 9%. There was a condition, NPR's Alina Selyukh reports: take a third of it now and repay it at $3,600 a day for 30 days, a test of his dependability, and the rest would follow. He paid. The rest never came. What he had signed, his funder EIN Cap later argued in court, was a merchant cash advance, which it had delivered.
The fraud claim is for a federal court in Los Angeles to settle, and EIN denies it. The more useful question is what was perfectly legal about the deal. NPR puts the industry's position in one line:
MCAs escape most lending laws because, technically, they are not loans.NPR
An advance is written as a purchase of the business's future sales. So the funder generally needs no license, and nothing caps what it charges: 25% to 200% and more once the fee is translated into an annual rate. Everything rests on the word “purchase.” Everything about how the money comes back says “loan.” The law should believe the second.
Start with what a purchase of future sales looks like. If you buy a slice of someone's receipts, you get paid when they sell and paid less when they don't. That variance is the risk the high price is supposed to cover. Shahinian's slice was $3,600 a day, a number fixed at signing before a single ticket sold, pulled straight from his bank account the way most funders collect. On day 40 the account hit zero. He kept paying to the end, took out more advances to keep his tour alive, and within weeks owed more than $1 million to friends and family.
Then look at what happens when a merchant can't pay. A buyer of future sales whose seller stops selling has made a bad purchase. EIN sued. Shahinian spent a year tracking down some 700 businesses it had taken to court for debt collection, a strange remedy for something that isn't a debt. In Washington state, EIN was ordered to return the daily fees it kept withdrawing from a business that was already insolvent. An insolvent company has no future sales to buy. It only has a balance to collect.
The industry's defense isn't empty. Banks reject about one in five small-business loan applications and only partly fund another quarter, per Treasury, and the SBA has tightened its rules. An advance arrives in hours. Shahinian used two of them to save an earlier tour after American Express wound down the cheap merchant financing he'd relied on, and he blames himself for waiting until the last minute. Push every advance under usury law and some of that emergency money goes away.
Grant all of that, and notice what it defends: a high price for taking a risk banks won't. A fixed daily draw hands that risk back to the merchant and keeps the price. The honest version of the product already exists. Revenue-based financing takes a percentage of what actually came in, so a bad month costs the funder too. The rule that separates the two is short. If the payment doesn't move with sales, it's a loan.
If the payment doesn't move with sales, it's a loan.
California is moving. A new law will require funders and brokers to be licensed and background-checked starting in 2028. That would have caught the man who sold Shahinian his test under the name Bryan Stein; the Brooklyn District Attorney's Office told NPR he pleaded guilty to grand larceny in 2012. It wouldn't have changed what Shahinian signed. Licensing polices who sells the product. It leaves alone what the product is.
The broker called those 30 days a test of whether Shahinian was dependable. They were a test of the advance, and day 40 answered it. A buyer of his future sales would have taken less that week. His funder still wanted $3,600.