Seventy-five percent. That is how much of All About Berlin's traffic Nicolas Bouliane says Google's AI Overviews have taken, in a post that was back near the top of Hacker News this week. He has run the site since 2017 and lived off it since 2020. Government offices refer people to his guides. The Berlin immigration office, he writes, uses his data about itself.
The rent is the headline. The line that matters is about the other site owners who wrote to him to commiserate. Some paywalled their work. Others gave up and moved on, and he describes what giving up looks like:
They keep the websites online, but they no longer update them. It's just not worth it.Nicolas Bouliane, All About Berlin
That is the real cost of the AI answer, and it doesn't show up on a traffic chart. An Overview isn't a replacement for somebody's guide. It's a summary of it, and the guide is only worth summarizing because someone keeps it current. The clicks paid for that. Take the clicks and the page stays up, but nobody keeps it true.
The click loss is no longer an anecdote. In a randomized trial summarized this month by RevScope, an analytics vendor that says as much, Saharsh Agarwal and Ananya Sen hid Overviews from a random group of US desktop Chrome users for two weeks early this year. On searches that would show an Overview, people who saw it made 0.37 clicks to outside sites per search. People who didn't made 0.62. That is a 40% cut. Searches ending with no outside click rose from 54% to 73%. Clicks on ads didn't move. Overviews now appear on 61% of the 20 million keywords DataForSEO tracks, up from 6% in September 2024, and on 70% of informational searches, the kind All About Berlin exists to answer.
Here is the part that should worry Google as much as Bouliane: the answers lean hardest on the work the clicks used to fund. SISTRIX paired 48,527 pages cited by AI answers with uncited pages from the same sites. The strongest signal was the current year in the title. Those pages were cited 2.7 times as often, which SISTRIX reads as a rough stand-in for maintained content rather than a title trick. A visible last-updated date helped most on editorial sites. The engines prefer fresh pages. Freshness is labor. The labor was paid for by visits.
Take the clicks and the page stays up, but nobody keeps it true.
Google says nothing is broken. Liz Reid, who runs Search, wrote in August 2025 that total organic clicks were "relatively stable" and that Google was sending "slightly more quality clicks." She published no figures. The trial puts the loss across all searches at roughly 18.5% of a site's organic clicks from Google. The usual fix on offer, getting cited, doesn't close the gap either: Pew watched real browsing and saw people click a link inside a summary on 1% of visits.
The better objection is about readers, not publishers. Someone who wanted the boiling point of water got it faster, and nobody needs to maintain the boiling point of water. Grant it. A fact that never changes doesn't need an author. But people search because the answer changes: which form, which office, which fee, which appointment system this year. Those are the pages worth quoting, and they're worth quoting because someone keeps them current.
So the failure is slow and quiet. No page goes dark. No error appears. The Overview keeps answering, citing a guide whose author stopped updating it a year ago, in the same confident register it used when the guide was current. Bouliane says he already spends his days preparing for another way to pay rent instead of writing new guides. The immigration office will keep changing its rules either way.
The site will stay up. The summary will stay sure of itself. Only the facts will move.