Clamp the arteries that carry blood to the head. Then cut holes in them, so whatever the clamp misses drains out. And don't give the donor a paralytic, because it could mask movement. Those are among the first national rules for normothermic regional perfusion, which the organ transplant network's board approved on Nov. 6 and which take effect Dec. 6, on an emergency basis, before the public had a chance to weigh in.

NRP happens after a family has decided to withdraw care. The heart stops, the patient is declared dead by circulatory criteria, and minutes later surgeons attach an external pump that restarts blood flow to the heart, lungs, kidneys and liver so the organs don't deteriorate before retrieval. The federal agency that oversees transplants sees it as a way to get more organs, and better ones.

Read the safeguards again. Each one guards against something that can only happen to a patient whose brain could come back. You don't need to drain warm blood away from a dead brain. You don't need to keep paralytics away from a body so you can watch it move. The new policy is careful, and its care is the confession: it treats death as a condition the surgical team has to maintain, not a fact it has already observed.

In order to be dead by circulatory criteria it means we're not going to attempt to reestablish circulation. But that's exactly what they do in NRP.
Dr. Lainie Friedman Ross, to NPR

That is the problem in two sentences. Circulatory death isn't a reading on a monitor. It's a declaration that circulation is gone and no one will bring it back. NRP brings it back, then clamps off the head so the brain stays out of it. Dr. Claire Morgan, the transplant surgeon who first reported the cases to federal regulators, told NPR that teams have "seen signs of life in NRP when the brain has been reperfused." The new rule's answer is a second cut, one that critics say most surgeons were already making.

This isn't a case against organ donation as most people know it. Donation after brain death restarts nothing. Neither does conventional donation after circulatory death, which waits for the heart to stay stopped and then retrieves. NRP is the one procedure where the circulation that defined death comes back inside the donor.

The case for it isn't cynical, and it deserves its full weight. More than 109,000 Americans are waiting for an organ, and about 12 die every day. The donors in question have no prospect of meaningful recovery, their families have already chosen to withdraw care, and better-perfused organs make for better transplants. Dr. Raymond Lynch, who directs transplantation at HRSA, calls NRP "life-saving care" that is safe "if it is done properly." All of that is true.

None of it is an argument that the donor is dead. It's an argument that, given everything else, it shouldn't matter whether the donor is dead in the sense the rule means. That is a different rule. It can be argued for. It should be argued for in public, by the people who want it. Instead the system keeps the dead donor rule's words and moves its substance into technique: clamp, vent, keep the paralytics out. Every organ in the system is given on one promise, to the patient on the table and to everyone who checks the box at the DMV: nothing will be taken until you are dead. A promise that has to be held up by a second clamp is being renegotiated, and the other party to it wasn't asked.

The new policy is careful, and its care is the confession.

If the transplant system believes NRP donors are dead, it doesn't need the second cut. If it needs the second cut, it owes the public the argument it skipped.